Intelligence is a way of assembling puzzles with missing pieces, often starting in medias res. It’s a challenging task that can require specific training in fields such as data analysis, signal interception, image reading, and interpersonal communication, depending on the type of information being gathered. Regardless of whether it’s FININT or SOCMINT, it requires creativity, mental flexibility, ingenuity, lateral thinking, and divergent thinking.
Contrary to common belief, partly shaped by Hollywood and partly due to the actual secrecy many intelligence agencies operate under, intelligence has never been a profession reserved for an elite few. This explains why some of the greatest collectors of information and saboteurs in history—both past and recent—have been unlikely (and thus unsuspected) civilians, recruited for various purposes: from Aleister Crowley to Rasputin.
But intelligence is not only about espionage and conspiracies. It can also involve access to data sources, deciphering images, geolocation, interrogations disguised as interviews, and much more.
We discussed the many ways of conducting intelligence and the meaning of one of its most debated forms in the modern era—misunderstood OSINT—with Professor Alberto Pagani, one of the top experts in the field. A contract professor at the University of Bologna since 2022, he has taught about intelligence and national security at various institutions, including Link Campus University, LUMSA, SIOI, and UNICAL, and served as a Member of Parliament for two terms, including as the Democratic Party’s group leader on the Defense Committee.
Intelligence is a multifaceted field. We have economic intelligence, cybersecurity intelligence, open-source intelligence, human intelligence, and the emerging blockchain intelligence. These categories have subcategories, such as dark web intelligence and social media intelligence, forming a puzzle whose resolution can impact national security. In an increasingly complex world that is also more open and interconnected than ever, how has the way intelligence is conducted changed, and what are the primary challenges in gathering information?
I learned from aikido that it’s wrong and dangerous to conceptually break down an action into partial body movements because, if you can’t then reassemble them in a harmonious way to perform the action fluidly, it loses all its effectiveness. Unlike martial arts focused on linear movements, aikido mainly develops through circular dynamics, with the pivot being the one who is being attacked. To defend themselves, they stabilize their center of gravity by rotating, causing the attacker to lose balance as they are drawn into the attacker’s orbit. However, the action works only if the movement is fluid because the energy of the attack is neutralized by assimilating it. So aikido is not a series of self-defense techniques to memorize, but a practice based on a holistic approach and harmony. I imagine this might seem like a strange answer, but I think intelligence is a bit like aikido: if you want to break it down into a thousand specific categories, in the end, you need to be able to reassemble them to truly understand something.
Could you explain with an example?
Of course: a cyberattack can serve as a tool in economic warfare, which requires a geopolitical interpretation, and thus knowledge of history, anthropology, and religion to be fully understood. Take the Iranian “Shamoon” attack, also known as W32.DistTrak, for example, which on August 15, 2012, infected three-quarters of Saudi Arabia’s oil company’s computers worldwide. Saudi Aramco is an economic giant that pumps huge amounts of oil into the market every day and contributes to more than 80% of Saudi Arabia’s GDP. This malware didn’t encrypt the data to demand a ransom, but instead irreparably damaged hard drives, then displayed an image of the American flag burning on the infected terminal screens. The cyberattack shut down extraction activities for several days, and fortunately, the infection did not spread from IT (Information Technology) systems to OT (Operational Technology) systems; otherwise, the damage would have been even worse, even for us Italians, who don’t even know Saudi Aramco exists.
Why could this cyberattack have affected us too?
Because the halt in Saudi extraction caused a temporary spike in the Western market price of oil due to reduced supply and subsequent speculation. When oil prices increase, it also raises electricity costs, which increases industrial production costs, leading to higher consumer prices, i.e., inflation. It’s like the butterfly effect, where the flap of a butterfly’s wings in Brazil is said to cause a tornado in Texas. The increase in variation in dynamic systems is the paradigm we need to reference, which, in this case, forces us to see correlations between distinct fields of knowledge that appear distant from a disciplinary standpoint. Shamoon is not an example of cybercrime, but of cyberwarfare, and it’s incomprehensible if observed through the lens of a computer technician or a police officer pursuing a cybercrime. In fact, the attribution to Iran is still unproven: if we were to go to court, I believe Tehran’s regime would be acquitted. Intelligence doesn’t conduct criminal investigations and doesn’t search for evidence of criminal guilt—it seeks information to understand what is happening and, as far as possible, predict what might happen. It’s a different kind of work, done in a different way.
So, did this cyberattack aim to produce an economic advantage for Iranian oil producers? Or a political advantage for Iran?
Both, but not just for the Iranians. Iran is the most sanctioned “rogue state” in the world. Western countries, which don’t buy Iranian oil, are more affected by the energy price hike than countries that don’t impose sanctions, like China. Then there are major oil producers, like Russia, that automatically benefit from the price increase because their product is paid for at a higher rate. An engineer studying the cyberattack purely from a cybersecurity intelligence perspective wouldn’t see this, as they don’t deal with the dynamics of the oil market and its economic effects. Only the reassembly of knowledge allows us to truly understand what is happening, which is what the political decision-maker needs to comprehend.
You are a reference figure in the field. You are one of the co-founders of the Italian Society of Intelligence (SOCINT) and have served on the Defense Committee. I would like to hear your personal definition of intelligence.
I still consider myself an amateur because I enjoy learning what I don’t know, which is much more than what I do know. In any case, to answer your question, I’ll give two definitions. The first is in a narrow sense: intelligence as the activity of gathering and analyzing secret information for national security purposes. The second is more expansive, as it refers to the method of intelligence, which is not applied only in government contexts but also in business, for example. In the latter case, information gathering serves to ensure security and guide the economic strategies of private companies, in pursuit of their legitimate interests, which may incidentally align with national security, but not necessarily. The method of intelligence is rigorous and scientific—it’s not just espionage, but also validation, classification, and processing of the gathered information. Today, most of the information needed can be found through open sources, but we know that on the World Wide Web, everything and its opposite can be found, so without a rigorous method, there is no intelligence.
In the era of information societies and the boom in open-source intelligence (OSINT), it’s now possible to identify threats, map movements (including of troops), and intercept trends without needing a cell or agent on the ground. With OSINT, and more specifically SOCMINT, useful data for cognitive operations can also be gathered. The question isn’t whether OSINT will completely replace HUMINT, but rather, what future does HUMINT have in a world that allows (almost) everything to be discovered through OSINT?
We all generate and leave an unimaginable amount of data on the internet for the generation of our parents. Whoever is able to find, extract, correlate, and analyze it can learn a lot about each of us. But the fact that all our daily actions are traceable and traced, and that the amount of information we publish online is truly vast, doesn’t mean that good OSINT alone will uncover everything. Moreover, with the latest-generation analytical algorithms, analyzing Big Data allows us to profile each of us very accurately and precisely, even making predictions about our future behavior. In the 1950s, when Isaac Asimov described a technology combining history, psychology, and statistics to predict future events in his science fiction Foundation series, I believe he was already imagining something that resembles what has come to pass in our time. Today, by analyzing Big Data, we can really extract incredible information, identify significant correlations, and influence future trends. But all this is not the prophecy of the Oracle of Delphi—it’s hypotheses, which become more useful when compared and correlated with human-source information. There’s a human ability to observe, intuit, and understand that machines still can’t replicate, even with artificial intelligence, which learns based on statistics and doesn’t have any intuition. Human intuition is still inimitable and necessary, even in intelligence.
In 2024, you curated a multi-author publication for Donzelli Editore titled Hard Times. The New Wars and European Defense, which included contributions from former Defense Chief of Staff Giuseppe Cavo Dragone, General Fernando Giancotti, and some of Italy’s leading political scientists, such as Mario Caligiuri and Giuseppe Gagliano. In this book, you discussed China and the challenge it poses to the Western-led international order and the United States, particularly from economic and technological perspectives: from the New Silk Road to telecommunications, including the automotive and aerospace sectors. I’d love to hear your prediction on the confrontation shaping our era: which direction are we headed in?
I don’t believe the challenge is between the United States and China, but between the liberal and democratic West, which includes us, and authoritarian countries, where unbridled capitalism coexists with dictatorial political regimes. China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea form a political and military alliance in practice, as we’ve seen both in the war in Ukraine and in the Middle East. It’s not just about converging interests, but about a political plan to expand their sphere of influence in developing countries, as seen in Africa or Central-Southern Asia, and to build interest convergence with large countries like India or Brazil. The problem is that the globalized economy and the rivalry between powers are two concrete realities that don’t fit well together. The contradiction lies in the fact that global industrial supply chains exist, meaning economic systems are interdependent and difficult to decouple. Apple phones are made in China, and if they were made in America, they’d cost a fortune. It’s not easy to manage these contradictions. At the same time, economic competition is unfair—it’s not a level playing field, but rather a game played with fraud and tricks, making the direction this process of globalization has taken unsustainable for the West. The world order based on the Washington Consensus no longer exists; we are in the midst of disorder, which is creating dangerous monstrosities, and it’s not at all easy to escape from it. We need to build a new order.

Add a Comment