PHOTO-2024-11-29-19-49-13

Diplomacy and Culture Are the Solution to War and Fanaticism

After an ensemble of ordinary experiences as judicial police in Italy, which were part of my daily routine, I had the opportunity to work abroad on investigations into organized crime, war crimes, and terrorism. Abroad, it often happened that, alongside work meetings, I would end up having dinner with so-called experts, usually sent by the European Union or the United Nations, to get to know each other better in the prospect of future collaboration in the field. Working alongside them in the field, it became clear that the only thing they had as “experts” was the title itself, as their knowledge was based on ‘copy-pasting’ other people’s work, and their analyses were transcriptions of what those who had actually gained experience on the ground had said.

The moments of conviviality were particularly interesting because it was at the dinner table that the most important issues and questions would arise. I remember an ambassador, I can’t recall whether from the United Kingdom or the United States, who later went on to work for the United Nations, asking me: “As a police officer, how do you assess your intervention and role here in Kosovo in terms of effectiveness and efficiency?”. I replied that our work was essentially useless, because the police operate in the acute phase, like the emergency room of a hospital, which means that by the time we arrive, it’s already too late. It’s obvious that when you’re at the crime scene, you act immediately, and there’s no Plan B, much like when someone is about to die and needs emergency intervention. But if there is a lack of prophylaxis, health education, prevention, rehabilitation, etc., the emergency intervention is ultimately pointless. Well, we are the emergency room, and if education, prevention, family, and schools are lacking, socially speaking, the situation doesn’t change.

When I use the emergency room example, I often refer to Kosovo, because it was there that we were truly operational, whereas in Bosnia we played more of an advisory role. As for me, having been in Bosnia during the final years of the EU missions in Yugoslavia, it was more of an analytical, reading, research, and study job.

Anyway, the ambassador’s reaction to my answer was one of ‘surprise’ and curiosity. I realize that my response wasn’t the ‘typical’ one from a police officer, but more from a civilian who was living in Kosovo at that time and, outside of working hours, was spending time with the local people, interacting with children, the elderly, and women, who were the true victims of the wars.

From my personal experience, especially in Kosovo, I learned that our work is effective only if everything else is in place and that if you intervene on the causes, you will start seeing results in the second or third generation. Because prevention is achieved through education. And in this context, the role of schools is fundamental, both for their educational value and for the space they provide for coexistence between people.

I remember that in Kosovo, children attended school in two shifts because many schools had been bombed. The two shifts covered morning and afternoon, so I would observe the “new generations” from dawn to dusk and wonder what would become of them, aware that my “police intervention” was just a segment of what was necessary in that context, for those people. I would compare notes with the interpreters working with us, all of them very young university graduates, but who had grown up quickly due to the war. I hoped to gain their trust to understand, engage, and apologize. That was the real challenge. School, family, culture, and traditions were the real tools for those people wounded in the soul even more than in the body.

Territories ravaged by wars, terrorism, and mafias have one thing in common: radicalization takes root in places where there is misery and poverty, while ignorance and the inability to attend school do the rest, as they prevent young people from forming their own thoughts. Different contexts, but the same mechanisms: it’s necessary to intervene in schools and invest in education and culture, not just in military and police forces. And I am even more convinced of this today, now that I am retired and limit myself to observing and, when possible, sharing my experience with those who are willing to listen.

Politics can and must play a role in building cultures of dialogue. It is politics, after all, that should have a vision and make investments to bring that vision to life over the long term for future generations. But today, unfortunately, we have political classes that possess no vision, either domestic or international, and thus navigate blindly. Every political intervention is characterized by short-sighted interpretations of events, whether it’s about schools, healthcare, or security. Today, we are witnessing the absence of visionary politicians, or at least the absence of politicians willing to care for collective interests.

It is not populism to claim that politicians of the past were different. Let’s be clear: they were also primarily concerned with maintaining power, but at the same time, they had visions, whether they were shareable or not, that are now completely absent. Take, for example, the events in Ukraine and Israel: in both cases, it seems that the sole intention of the leaders is to create total disaster in order to sell as many weapons as possible, even resorting to the creation of “counterfeit massacres,” where the bodies don’t bleed, to give an example. And if some, very few, war correspondents raise doubts, they are immediately silenced.

Today’s politics does intervene, but in the most crude and materialistic sense of the term: a casus belli is found to enter a country, and then its resources are looted to cause the collapse of the economy. Today’s politics consists of wandering the world looking for windows to break, with the new one ready for replacement in one’s pocket: creating a problem and then offering the ready-made solution. But this is not politics, not politics in the highest sense of the word; it is extortion. We saw this in the gas pipeline wars between the United States and Russia, which peaked with the “announced sabotage” of Nord Stream 2 by the United States.

I would go so far as to say that, politics aside, diplomacy is no longer present, at least from what leaks out from public information. Moreover, the profession of a diplomat, unfortunately, is one that, for career reasons, can turn even the most talented into ‘yes men’. This is the major problem with public administration officials: career or integrity. On the other hand, there are always those who choose loyalty to the job, to the oath, and who, if necessary, would be willing to call out their superior or offer unsolicited and unwelcome advice. In this sense, the diplomat should be the one who advises the politician, whether the latter has a vision or not.

My reading of the current and future international context is pessimistic. Although I hope I am wrong, I remember that a year ago, during an interview on the Israeli-Palestinian crisis, I said the following: “If the Israelis will wipe the slate clean, it means that the interests are of a geo-energetic nature.” I said this using the example of the 1972 Munich attacks, to which Israel responded by identifying the perpetrators and masterminds of the massacre one by one. Why, today, unlike back then, is Israel proceeding with systematic destruction? Because it can afford to completely control a territory previously inhabited by another people, in order to exploit the Gaza Marina gas field and maybe even build the much-discussed Ben Gurion Canal. And we still don’t know why the terrorist attack warnings from Egypt, the United States, and even Israel’s own intelligence services were ignored.

Reading the Israeli-Palestinian war from this geo-energetic perspective, the strategy of wiping the slate clean makes sense: it is preparatory to transforming Israel into the energy and commercial hub of Southeast Mediterranean. And here enters the aforementioned lack of vision, a flaw that afflicts both Western and non-Western politicians alike, because questions must be asked about what fruits will emerge from the seeds Israel has planted in this war, and how powers like Turkiye will react to an Israel strengthened in the coming years.

But there’s more. I believe that Israel has planted seeds, always through this violent conflict with the Palestinians, that are destined to take shape: tomorrow’s terrorists. This is a forecast based on my knowledge of the Middle Eastern context, where the religious factor is still very strong and makes the future resurgence of terrorism more likely than not. We may not see phenomena like ISIS, which structured itself as a political and administrative entity based on the Quran, but we will witness terrorism in the form of hijackings, car bombings, stabbings, and suicide bombers. This last form of terrorism will reappear with greater force and will be difficult to combat.

It is necessary, with a long-term horizon in mind, to invest in schools, family, culture, and diplomacy. And I’m not only referring to the Middle East, but also to Europe, where between Russia and Ukraine, it has been preferred to escalate the conflict to maximum intensity and abandon dialogue as a means of resolving differences, even when they are fierce. This happened because diplomacy found an insurmountable obstacle in an uninvited guest: the arms lobbies, the only ones making “infinite” profits off the blood of the innocent.

New ways of thinking about diplomacy are needed. Looking east, at the BRICS+, we have a great example of collaboration among major powers blending political goals and economic interests. It’s a format that requires time, as the decision-making process is shared equally, but it has proven to work. We cannot continue with the traditional politics of the past, based on imposing one’s will through force. We must devise new ideas.

If I look back, I remember when we used to play football at the parish or in the park, where the owner of the ball would decide the field and the goalkeeper, and everyone had to “submit” if they wanted to play. It’s the same in politics: the one who controls the essential tools decides, and often it is the most aggressive one, not necessarily the most balanced. Perhaps it’s time to think about bringing our own ball from home so that we don’t depend on others.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *