Revisiting the past of relations between nations can be key to understanding their present—and to anticipating their future. Not because what happened yesterday is bound to repeat itself today, but because it helps strip away the illusion of exceptionalism that often surrounds current events, presenting them as entirely new or unprecedented.
Applying this reasoning to the complex Turkish-Israeli relationship means treating the leaders’ periodic incendiary statements with caution—and favoring instead an analysis grounded in facts. Only by doing so can we begin to understand whether the future of Ankara and Tel Aviv holds the seeds of armed confrontation or the strengthening of cooperation.
A Possible War?
The compelling hypothesis of a deepening rivalry—one that could eventually escalate into open conflict—must be weighed against several significant factors. Chief among them is Turkey’s membership in NATO. While it is clear that this membership is of a sui generis nature, Ankara continues to benefit from both direct and indirect advantages, including security guarantees and access to advanced military technology.
It is true that Israel is not part of the Atlantic Alliance, but its privileged relationship with Washington and several European countries makes it highly likely that any aggression against it would trigger far-reaching consequences. These repercussions could take the form of a major diplomatic and political crisis within NATO itself, leading to Turkey’s marginalization within the Alliance. A “Turkexit,” on the other hand, would remain a worst-case scenario—one triggered by Ankara’s own voluntary choice, as NATO has no formal mechanism for expelling member states.
Such ostracization would be a heavy blow for Turkey, which—despite its sharp criticisms—is far from seeking isolation within the Alliance. This is all the more true today, as Ankara is pushing with increasing determination to (re)integrate into a European security architecture.
Economic War
Beyond potential isolation within NATO, Ankara would almost certainly face economic sanctions, which—given the structural limitations and vulnerabilities of the Turkish economy—could have paralyzing effects. Unlike Russia, which has shown a high degree of resilience in the face of economic restrictions, particularly during the war in Ukraine, Turkey is deeply integrated into the European market. This interdependence makes Ankara especially vulnerable to coercive measures from Western countries.
Moreover, the United States, by leveraging its influence over global financial markets, could act directly on the lira-dollar exchange rate, targeting Turkey’s perpetually fragile currency. A further depreciation of the Turkish lira would not only worsen domestic inflation but also increase the cost of imports—exerting substantial economic pressure on the country’s already strained economy.
Back to 1916
The fallout from a war with Israel would be significant from both strategic and diplomatic standpoints. First and foremost, the United States—potentially in a retaliatory posture—could escalate its operational support for Kurdish terrorism, which Ankara considers the primary threat to its national security. This would likely occur alongside a broader reinforcement of U.S. positions in the Middle East as a means of deterrence.
Relations with the monarchies of the Arabian Peninsula would also be affected. These countries, which spent the 2000s strengthening commercial and financial ties with Turkey, maintain strong relations with Israel—especially in the realm of security. Any offensive against Israel could jeopardize the delicate balance between Ankara and the Gulf states, likely to Turkey’s detriment.
The leading powers of the world would likely side with Israel, though perhaps not all of them explicitly. Ankara’s expansionist agenda—often described as neo-Ottomanism—has extended Turkish influence across several parts of the region, but it has been more tolerated than welcomed. The Saudis, Emiratis, and Egyptians are all waiting for a moment of Turkish weakness to strike back. It would be a return to 1916: Arabs against Ottomans. Only this time, the new Lawrence of Arabia would likely be of American or Israeli descent.
A Losing Crisis
All signs suggest that Turkey stands to lose from any escalation of tensions with Israel. This is not only because of the extensive technological and commercial ties between the two countries, but above all because the likely and multifaceted retaliations—coming from multiple directions—could diplomatically isolate Ankara and cripple it economically.
Not least, the Middle Eastern chaos unleashed by a Turkish-Israeli escalation would open the door for a weakened Iran to reinsert itself into the region’s power dynamics—regaining strength and prestige by exploiting the cracks created by the conflict. An eternal return to the past.

Add a Comment