indopacifico

Taiwan: A Tale of Two Chinas – Part II

On January 1, 1912, the Chinese Empire collapsed, giving way to the Republic of China, proclaimed in Nanjing by Sun Yat-sen. As early as 1905, Sun had founded the Chinese Revolutionary Alliance in Tokyo—a movement built on three core principles for the Chinese people: national unity, popular rights, and collective well-being.

The Alliance became the ideological engine behind a wave of protests that culminated in the Wuchang Uprising, the spark that ignited the 1911 Chinese Revolution. Efforts by the Qing rulers to turn the empire into a constitutional monarchy proved futile: one by one, the provinces declared their loyalty to Sun Yat-sen and his Alliance, while others—such as Tibet and Outer Mongolia—proclaimed their independence. The Mandate of Heaven had been withdrawn from the Qing, unexpectedly laying the groundwork for what would become the Taiwan question.

The Origins of the Two Chinas

At this point in history, three dates become crucial: August 25, 1912; July 1, 1921; and March 12, 1925. On August 25, 1912, Sun Yat-sen founded the Kuomintang (KMT), a party that would go on to play a central role in relations between China and Taiwan. On July 1, 1921, Mao Zedong and others founded the Chinese Communist Party (CCP); on March 12, 1925, Sun Yat-sen died and was succeeded at the helm of the Kuomintang by Chiang Kai-shek—another key figure in the Beijing–Taipei relationship. At first, the KMT and the CCP worked together. Given the CCP’s close ties to the Soviet Union, the Kuomintang sought the support of a foreign power of its own.

But tensions between the two parties escalated quickly and eventually led to a complete rupture. In 1927, Chiang Kai-shek orchestrated the Shanghai Massacre and violently suppressed peasant revolts in Guangzhou. Through force, he managed to unify much of the country and asserted control over former Qing territories—including Taiwan, which was brought back under Chinese control in 1945. He concentrated all five branches of power—executive, legislative, judicial, supervisory, and examination—under the State Council, which he chaired. Meanwhile, on August 1, 1927, the CCP created the Red Army to defend itself against the attacks from Chiang and the Kuomintang, who by then had secured backing from the United States and the United Kingdom.

The Communist Party’s response came swiftly. As Japan invaded Manchuria, the CCP proclaimed the Chinese Soviet Republic on November 7, 1930, with Mao Zedong as its Prime Minister. The civil war had begun. However, it wasn’t until after Japan’s surrender on September 9, 1945, that the fighting escalated dramatically. In 1947, Chiang Kai-shek’s nationalists, supported by the United States, launched massive military campaigns across the country—despite having signed an agreement with Mao in July 1946 to rebuild China after the war with Japan. The communists held their ground and soon began launching counter-offensives.

1949: China Divided

Emboldened by this resistance, Mao issued a call on April 30, 1948, to convene a national conference of party leaders and civil society representatives. The call was met with widespread support, and after Chiang’s final offensive failed in January 1949—with devastating losses—the conference was held in Beijing at the end of September. On October 1, 1949, Mao proclaimed the founding of the People’s Republic of China. The nationalists, under Chiang’s leadership, fled en masse to Taiwan.

There, they re-established the entire institutional structure of the state and founded the Republic of China, positioning it as the continuation and legitimate heir of the state established by Sun Yat-sen in 1912. Formally, however, Japan only relinquished sovereignty over Taiwan in 1951 with the signing of the Treaty of San Francisco, which notably did not specify whether the island belonged to the People’s Republic or was independent. In any case, the paths of Taiwan and mainland China had (perhaps definitively) diverged.

From the outset, Chiang Kai-shek imposed martial law in Taiwan, a measure that would remain in force until 1987. This period is known as the “White Terror” era. The regime led first by Chiang and then by his son, Chiang Ching-kuo, was decidedly authoritarian. The main targets of repression were Taiwan’s Indigenous populations, who at the time outnumbered the ethnic Chinese who had arrived in 1949. These native groups were stripped of their civil and political rights; in an effort to assimilate and “Sinicize” them, local languages were banned and replaced with Mandarin. Tensions between the newcomers and the Indigenous communities were violently suppressed. It is estimated that over 100,000 people were arrested, tortured, or even executed for alleged ties to the Chinese Communist Party or opposition to the Kuomintang.

Despite the Kuomintang’s early focus on suppressing dissent and enforcing Sinicization, the Chiang regime promoted rapid economic growth throughout the 1960s and ’70s. Leveraging infrastructure left behind by the Japanese, Taiwan’s economy was steered toward industrial and technological production. By the early 1970s, Taipei had become the second-fastest-growing economy in Asia after Tokyo—thanks in part to U.S. aid, including a $4 billion package in 1965 alone.

The Eagle Between Two Dragons

Washington quickly recognized the strategic importance of an autonomous Taiwan—one that needed to be kept close and protected. In addition to economic support, when the Korean War broke out in 1950, President Truman ordered the Seventh Fleet into the Taiwan Strait to deter Mao from launching attacks on the Matsu and Quemoy islands, which had just been occupied by Chiang Kai-shek. Mao, who saw the capture of Taiwan as a strategic imperative, was misled by the American naval presence and the (mistaken) belief that U.S. troops would invade China from Korea. As a result, he shifted his military focus to the Korean border.

The Matsu and Quemoy (or Kinmen) islands soon became the stage for the first Taiwan Strait Crisis. The People’s Liberation Army launched a heavy assault and seized control. Washington chose not to go to war, but it also couldn’t afford to lose Taiwan. In 1954, the U.S. and Taiwan signed a mutual defense treaty, obliging the United States to intervene in the event of a direct attack on the island—but not in the case of assaults on its smaller outlying territories. To reinforce deterrence, the U.S. Congress passed the Formosa Resolution in 1955, granting President Eisenhower full authority to defend not only Taiwan, but also its surrounding islands if necessary.

Aware of Taiwan’s geostrategic value, Mao in 1958 was willing to risk a direct conflict with Washington in an attempt to take it. He bombed Taiwan’s offshore islands and prepared his troops for an amphibious invasion, directly challenging both the treaty and the Formosa Resolution. The United States responded by reinforcing its military presence: the Seventh Fleet returned to the Strait, now equipped with nuclear-capable bombers, and all Taiwanese vessels were placed under American escort. Faced with a nation still reeling from a brutal civil war and in no position to confront Washington, Mao was forced to back down. The rest, as they say, is history.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *