The Dominican priest and Peruvian theologian Gustavo Gutiérrez, regarded as one of the fathers of Liberation Theology, passed away on Tuesday, October 22, 2024, in Lima at the age of 96. The announcement was made by the Bartolomé de las Casas Institute, a non-profit civil association founded by Gutiérrez in 1974, through a press release:
With deep sorrow, we announce that our dear friend and founder, Gustavo Gutiérrez, has passed away this evening. His work and dedication to the poor and the marginalized will continue to illuminate the path of the Church toward a more just and fraternal world.
Who Was Gutiérrez?
Gutiérrez is credited with making the most significant contribution to a completely new theological practice, often challenged by the Holy See: Liberation Theology. The Peruvian theologian, drawing on a deep reflection on the socio-cultural context of Latin America in the 1960s, questioned how to reconcile revolutionary struggle in Latin America with religious preaching and how to link theological practice with issues of underdevelopment and poverty. He coined the expression “preferential option for the poor,” which was to become an absolute priority for the Catholic Church in light of innovations introduced by the Second Vatican Council.
Given its innovative nature, the Second Vatican Council created a propulsive effect in those years, involving both the priestly world closest to the difficulties of the people and Christian democratic parties, encouraging them to support the more popular sectors. It also pushed the Latin American Church to insist on core values like freedom, democracy, and equality.
From that moment, a true revolutionary push began throughout Latin America, partly influenced by the echoes of the Cuban Revolution and the theories introduced by Brazilian Paulo Freire, which placed the human being at the center as the promoter of their own freedom, in contrast to “power unjustly exercised by certain dominant sectors, international tensions, and external neocolonialism.”
With his physical departure, the Peruvian religious leaves behind, and gifts us with, an invaluable theological and humanistic legacy that will continue to inspire generations driven by the desire to search for and promote the most just and equitable society possible.
Gutiérrez’s Thought
Through a combined analysis of classical biblical texts and writings by André Gunder Frank, the creator of the “Dependency Theory,” Gutiérrez developed an innovative reflection useful for interpreting the social issues that Latin America was facing.
The theologian categorically rejected the notion and the very idea of development policies, considering them guilty of reducing populations to mere economic and social objects, which had proven incapable of addressing the real causes of poverty.
The industrialized world, according to the priest, operated under the logic of centers and peripheries: the enrichment of a few countries had been perpetuated for centuries at the expense of the impoverishment of other states, causing a situation of material dependency with significant repercussions not only in the economic sphere but also in the cultural one. Similarly, the economic growth fueled by multinational corporations was not directed at leading these nations and peoples toward development but rather at improving the profits of the importing countries.
Given the above condition, resulting from the center-periphery logic, the key word, according to Gutiérrez, had to be “Liberation,” understood as a call for the creation of a society free from all forms of slavery. In the face of social injustice, and through a constant commitment to human liberation, both religious and non-religious individuals would be called to form a single dissenting voice, a powerful tool capable of dismantling unjust social structures.
In Latin America, what was called development actually had a negative meaning, as it failed to address the root causes of the problems afflicting the subcontinent. It was often identified with timid measures implemented by a government or exploiting social group that maintained the dependency link with the oppressed. Therefore, it was more appropriate to speak of a “process of liberation” that would make possible the achievement of more humane living conditions.
The Medellín Conference
The initiation of the Second Vatican Council coincided with a phase of profound political and social changes in Latin America, destined to become an increasingly heated area during the Cold War.
The transformative period that began with the Cuban Revolution of 1959 continued with the onset of authoritarian regimes and the U.S. invasion of the Dominican Republic in April 1965. This operation not only halted the programs of the Alliance for Progress but also brought many Latin American Catholics closer to Marxism, disappointed by the failure of the “desarrollista” policy, which aimed to tackle underdevelopment and poverty through industrialization and import substitution. It was within this context that the reformist agenda of the Second Vatican Council was fully applied.
At the Second Latin American Episcopal Conference held between August and September 1968 in Medellín, 146 bishops, cardinals, experts, and progressive bishops like Hélder Câmara, Samuel Ruiz, and Gutiérrez gathered to discuss the role the Latin American Church should play in light of the ongoing transformations.
At Medellín, strong criticisms emerged against the Latin American ruling classes, foreign capitalism, and harsh denunciations of poverty and social injustice—issues that had never been seriously or concretely addressed by the Latin American ecclesiastical world. In particular, there was an emphasis on the need to create a new social order based on justice and human rights. In Gutiérrez’s words, Medellín outlined a new decisive option for the Church, the “People of God,” which would from then on “help all individuals deprived of every social means to know and become aware of their rights and make good use of them.”
At Medellín, the condition of underdevelopment experienced by Latin American populations was openly denounced. This condition was seen as the result of poverty, marginalization, and alienation. Sub-issues caused by the dependency on industrialized metropolises in a cruel neocolonial mechanism destined to generate inevitable protests and aspirations for social justice. This situation was explicitly declared unjust, for the first time, not only by Marxist parties but also by the ecclesiastical world, which, in theological terms, deemed it a “sinful” situation requiring change.
A concept traditionally linked to the Christian world, the idea of “sin” began in Medellín to take on the characteristics of specific historical realities such as hunger, misery, and “oppressive and guilty economic and social structures.” These realities, according to the theologian, constituted “a sinful situation, and the main culprits of our states’ economic dependence are those forces desiring profit and reckless greed.”
Faced with this condition of sin, the episcopate could not fail to recognize that Latin America found itself in a situation of injustice that was legitimate to combat. This “institutionalized violence” reduced people to a state of dependency, depriving them of what they needed to live and fully understand the violation of their fundamental rights, which they were entitled to as human beings. Given this situation, Gutiérrez stated that “it should not surprise that in Latin America the temptation to resort to violence arises. One should not abuse the patience of a people who have endured for years a condition that others would hardly accept.”
Liberation Theology
The Latin American bishops of Gutiérrez’s school did not recommend a path of violence, which, nevertheless, was gradually emerging in the region; rather, they considered it less effective and much more dangerous compared to the dynamism of a people, conscious and organized, committed to peace and justice.
In fact, the theology born out of Medellín ultimately transformed the very figure of the priest, who began to interact more frequently with workers, inhabitants of the favelas, and marginalized urban populations, engaging more in politics and urging conservative bishops—delegitimized by their own clergy—to convert and approach everything that had been affirmed by the Second Vatican Council.
The real “enemy” for the progressive Catholic world in Latin America ceased to be Marxism, which gave way to injustice, understood as entirely contradictory to the evangelical message. And so it happened that some priests, taking their spiritual commitment to the extreme, found themselves compromised with the revolutionary cause. A completely new form of Catholicism took root, influenced by the Cuban Revolution and opposition to military regimes, led by movements inspired by Guevarism that became an indispensable space for political commitment, at a time when military regimes were eradicating every form of political expression and active participation.
This content was published as part of our partnership with Opinio Juris – Law and Politics Review, where it originally appeared.

Add a Comment