borghi

Africa, World’s Reservoir and Italy’s Destiny

Africa is a continent where a dual competition is taking place: internal and external. The internal competition arises from the fact that Africa does not present a homogeneous landscape, being a complex continent populated by fifty-four countries. This complexity becomes fertile ground for the hegemonic ambitions of great powers.

The northern part of Africa bears the consequences of the Arab Spring. The Sahel represents its vulnerable core, displaying a series of environmental, demographic, and security issues, which are exacerbated by the gradual replacement of French hegemony with a Russo-Chinese one, alongside bursts of jihadism – as seen with Boko Haram in Nigeria. Then, there is the equatorial zone, which promises to be the world’s great reservoir of raw materials, the southern region, which presents prospects and potential outcomes that should be followed with great attention, and the Horn of Africa.

The Horn of Africa is an extremely sensitive area due to the presence of Islamist terrorism, particularly in the Somali context, the role of Djibouti, which acts as a central hub of global military presence, and the gradual penetration of Turkey into this region.

This partial reconstruction should suffice to demonstrate how Africa is a field of geopolitical competition driven by external forces, while simultaneously being a space in reorganization due to internal forces. Additionally, I believe that Africa represents one of the pincers with which Russia has launched its offensive on Europe in recent years.

This pincer has two arms: the east-west flank and the north-south flank. The east-west flank is exemplified by the war in Ukraine and the Russian intervention in Syria, which have created the conditions for a structured and permanent presence of the Russian Navy and Army in the so-called “warm seas.” The north-south flank should be understood not only geographically but also within the logic of hybrid warfare, with Russia trying to increase its coercive power over Europe by, for example, influencing macro phenomena that weaken it, such as migration flows and the supply chains of raw materials and rare earths.

In addition to understanding the general situation, it is crucial to recognize that this vast continent plays a central role for us, as Italians and as Europeans. This is because the scale of the issues and the complexity of the events, along with the intertwining of geopolitical dynamics just described, make it practically impossible to provide a national and isolated response to these issues. The end of the Françafrique has shown us this.

The Mattei Plan, if it is to avoid being lost in the maze of ambitions and rhetoric, and if it is not to be reduced to a mere renaming of a pre-existing cooperation plan, must necessarily evolve from an instrument imagined and designed by a single country to a multilateral strategy, involving actors from the European Union and the Atlantic Alliance. On this issue, we cannot afford errors, ambiguity, or opportunism. The Meloni government is called upon to make an important decision on the eve of a period of US neo-isolationism, which could give Italy a stronger position in terms of its ability to stay in Europe and, at the same time, reinforce its subjectivity and identity.

Looking at Africa, we could and should push for the creation of a true European Union strategy for Africa – otherwise, there is the risk of irrelevance and wishful thinking. This leads to the need to more firmly support the strengthening of the European pillar. Also because, in the coming years, Africa will present both dangerous challenges and extraordinary opportunities for those who decide to be at the heart of history.

If Africa remains a crucial ground in the geopolitical competition between great powers, it will continue to exist in a state of instability, insecurity, and the emergence of significant difficulties, primarily for us Italians and Europeans. However, if we succeed in transforming it into a global laboratory, made of new models of multilateral cooperation, we could open up new scenarios. To build new models of coordination among great powers, however, it is necessary to get involved and work on it constantly.

We need to acquire an awareness: that Africa and the Mediterranean are full of places that shape our future. In Italy, on the contrary, we tend to interpret this continent as something distant, peripheral, marginal, something that, in short, should not concern us. In reality, we must have the ability to understand that our destiny goes through Africa.

Just as our ancestors called the Mediterranean the Mare Nostrum, today, we are realizing that, given global dynamics, the rapprochement of peoples, the intersection of cultures facilitated by the digital revolution, and migration flows driven by the climate crisis, this sea, long seen as a barrier, has become a meeting place. From a certain point of view, the Mediterranean is also a lake bordered by three great global powers – the United States, Russia, and China – whose influence we are sometimes too unaware of. Paraphrasing Trotsky: if we do not concern ourselves with Africa and the Mediterranean, they will concern themselves with us.

So, what should be the institutional response at the dawn of the African century? This is a question that urgently needs to be answered, as the approaches adopted so far, which have been sectoral policies – such as cooperation and counterterrorism – and bilateral agreements, have not produced results.

Any approach to Africa should take into account that the continent has become the heart of the Global South. Because in the new geopolitical chessboard taking shape, one can glimpse a trend: the transformation of BRICS into a G77 model, which, incorporating segments of the African Union, South America, and the Indo-sphere, manages to popularize the idea – for us, rather harmful – of “the West versus the Rest.”

The next step after becoming aware of Africa’s importance should be an institutional response at the European level, capable of giving the European Union a real presence on the continent and enabling it to effectively address its most urgent problems. There would be a need for a permanent European institution dedicated to Africa, which would mean moving beyond bilateral agreements between European and African countries and starting an era of negotiations between the United States of Europe and the African Union. This would take place within a framework of free trade between the two shores of the Mediterranean, which, if true to Jacques Delors’ assertion – that where markets and merchants pass, armies and weapons do not – could allow for an emulsion – from a structural perspective – of the overall system of intercontinental relations.

Finally, the new approach to Africa should differentiate itself from past and present models with a neocolonial imprint. Because even the relations maintained by Russia and China with Africa have a strongly exploitative dimension. A model that places equality and rights at the center, alongside non-intensive land exploitation, could constitute a new starting point.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *